Appraisals
Appraisal Standards & Legal Compliance
Each appraisal we produce is a thoroughly researched legal document designed to meet all IRS and insurance valuation requirements. We adhere to the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP), ensuring our reports meet ethical and performance standards accepted industry-wide.
Purpose of Appraisal
Art appraisals help in understanding the value of a piece or collection, but they are also essential to fulfill specific legal and financial requirements.
The first step in conducting an appraisal is to identify the appraisal's nature and purpose. The most common reasons that you may require an appraisal are:
Areas of Specialization
• American Art
• Contemporary Art
• Modern Art
• Impressionist Art
• 19th Century Art
• Southern Art
• Furniture
• Decorative Art
• Antiques, Silver & Porcelain
Types of Appraisals
Insurance Coverage
Artworks, furniture and antiques above around $1,500 - $5,000 (depending on the insurance company) are not covered under traditional umbrella homeowner’s insurance. In the unfortunate event of theft, damage, or loss, an insurance appraisal guarantees that you receive appropriate compensation and are able to replace or repair the artwork without suffering significant financial loss.
​
For the first year after an item is purchased, the insurer will use the price it was purchased for as the value to insure it for. Any changes in value after that year, will not be reflected on a high-priced item without an insurance appraisal document.
Art values can fluctuate over time due to changes in the market, artist recognition, and other factors. Regular insurance appraisals help keep your coverage current, reflecting any increases or decreases in the value of your collection. We recommend updating your insurance appraisal every 2-5 years to ensure that the valuation remains relevant and accurate.
Charitable Contribution (Donation)
Donation appraisals are essential for tax deduction purposes. To claim a tax deduction for a charitable contribution of artwork over $5,000, the IRS requires a qualified appraisal. A donation appraisal ensures that you meet these requirements by providing a detailed, compliant report prepared by a qualified appraiser. The appraisal must adhere to IRS regulations and include specific information to be considered valid.
​
Donation appraisals must adhere to strict guidelines imposed by the IRS and therefore tend to be labor intensive. For each work appraisers are required to illustrate examples of comparable sales and provide a detailed analysis and a thorough explanation of their valuation methodology.
​
As such, donation appraisals, really any appraisal that will go to the IRS to be reviewed, will take longer and cost more than other types of appraisals. As we charge by the hour, and the final cost will depend on how easily accessible information and sale data about the artist is and the amount of research required. More valuable works require more thorough research and a longer market analysis, as per the IRS.
​
To begin the process, we will first need a signed document from the institution confirming and recognizing the donation, such as a Deed of Gift or a Letter of Acceptance. After completing the appraisal, we'll send two hard copies to you and one to the institution, along with an IRS Form 8283, which they will sign and mail back to you for your taxes.
Estate Tax & Planning
Estate appraisals play a critical role in estate planning, tax calculations, asset distribution, and legal compliance. An estate appraisal serves as a foundational document for various financial and legal decisions by helping executors and attorneys determine the total value of the estate.
​
Fiduciaries, executors, and advisors rely on these appraisals to facilitate the fair transfer of assets during probate and to make decisions related to estate taxes, asset liquidation, and overall estate management. Estate appraisals ensure the equitable distribution of property among heirs, whether by sale or direct transfer, and establish the basis for capital gains taxes.
​
Additionally, estate appraisals are essential for meeting IRS filing requirements for estates that exceed the federal estate tax exemption threshold and need to file an estate tax return (Form 706). To meet IRS standards, estate appraisals must include comparable sales and detailed market analysis for each item. Typically, your attorney will advise you if an estate appraisal is necessary or recommended.
Damage & Loss
Damage and loss appraisals determine the value of artwork that has been compromised—whether due to natural disasters, accidents, theft, or other unfortunate events. These appraisals ensure fair compensation and provide essential documentation for insurance claims and legal purposes.
​
In some cases, an item or collection has suffered damage without a prior appraisal document. Before starting an appraisal, it is important to determine the value that you are looking for in your specific situation, for example, do you want to know the value of the work pre-damage, post-damage, or the diminished value? Or are you looking to understand the cost to repair the item?
​
Ultimately, damage and loss appraisals facilitate the recovery process by ensuring that owners receive fair compensation for their losses. Whether through insurance payouts, legal settlements, or restoration efforts, the appraisal provides a foundation for moving forward after an unfortunate event.
By obtaining a professional damage and loss appraisal from M. Clayton Brown, you can ensure that your artwork is accurately evaluated, and you receive the support and compensation needed to address the damage effectively.